Who AI recommends for car insurance
A driver or household in the United States choosing an auto insurance company for price, coverage, and claims service.
The ranking
- State Farm is named in 78% of 240 answers, likely 72% to 83%.
- USAA is named in 70% of 240 answers, likely 64% to 75%.
- GEICO is named in 67% of 240 answers, likely 60% to 72%.
- Progressive is named in 64% of 240 answers, likely 58% to 70%.
- Travelers is named in 53% of 240 answers, likely 47% to 59%.
- Nationwide is named in 32% of 240 answers, likely 26% to 38%.
- Allstate is named in 28% of 240 answers, likely 23% to 34%.
- Erie Insurance is named in 25% of 240 answers, likely 20% to 31%.
- Auto-Owners Insurance is named in 22% of 240 answers, likely 17% to 28%.
- Liberty Mutual is named in 15% of 240 answers, likely 11% to 20%.
- American Family Insurance is named in 13% of 240 answers, likely 9% to 18%.
- Farmers Insurance is named in 12% of 240 answers, likely 9% to 17%.
- Lemonade is named in 7% of 240 answers, likely 4% to 11%.
- Root Insurance is named in 0% of 240 answers, likely 0% to 2%.
By engine
- State Farm. ChatGPT 78%, Gemini 83%, Google AI Mode 85%, Google AI Overviews 88%, Perplexity 75%, Claude 60%.
- USAA. ChatGPT 45%, Gemini 78%, Google AI Mode 83%, Google AI Overviews 78%, Perplexity 70%, Claude 68%.
- GEICO. ChatGPT 68%, Gemini 78%, Google AI Mode 65%, Google AI Overviews 63%, Perplexity 70%, Claude 58%.
- Progressive. ChatGPT 73%, Gemini 83%, Google AI Mode 68%, Google AI Overviews 73%, Perplexity 40%, Claude 50%.
- Travelers. ChatGPT 45%, Gemini 45%, Google AI Mode 55%, Google AI Overviews 53%, Perplexity 65%, Claude 55%.
- Nationwide. ChatGPT 25%, Gemini 33%, Google AI Mode 33%, Google AI Overviews 25%, Perplexity 45%, Claude 30%.
- Allstate. ChatGPT 23%, Gemini 28%, Google AI Mode 30%, Google AI Overviews 55%, Perplexity 20%, Claude 15%.
- Erie Insurance. ChatGPT 23%, Gemini 20%, Google AI Mode 23%, Google AI Overviews 23%, Perplexity 35%, Claude 28%.
Findings
- State Farm leads car insurance on AI answers with 78% of answers across six engines, ahead of USAA at 70%.
- Gemini names Progressive in 83% of car insurance answers, while Perplexity names it in 40%.
- 1 of the 14 car insurance brands we track is never named by ChatGPT in any answer in the last 30 days.
- Ask AI for the best car insurance on a budget and GEICO comes up 100% of the time, more than any other brand.
Week by week
- State Farm. 78%, 78%, weekly from 2026-11-09.
- USAA. 70%, 70%, weekly from 2026-11-09.
- GEICO. 61%, 73%, weekly from 2026-11-09.
- Progressive. 63%, 65%, weekly from 2026-11-09.
- Travelers. 57%, 49%, weekly from 2026-11-09.
- Nationwide. 32%, 32%, weekly from 2026-11-09.
- Allstate. 32%, 25%, weekly from 2026-11-09.
- Erie Insurance. 24%, 26%, weekly from 2026-11-09.
The sites AI cites
- cnbc.com, cited in 39% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- insurify.com, cited in 33% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- nerdwallet.com, cited in 33% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- moneygeek.com, cited in 27% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- thezebra.com, cited in 25% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- forbes.com, cited in 23% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- usnews.com, cited in 19% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- wallethub.com, cited in 18% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- insurance.com, cited in 17% of 235 answers that cite a source.
- marketwatch.com, cited in 17% of 235 answers that cite a source.
See where your brand stands, free and with no sign-up.
How we measure
Every week we ask each buyer question once on each of six engines, which are ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, and Claude. ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google's two AI answers are read as a person in the United States sees them, with no account history. Perplexity and Claude are asked through their makers' APIs with web search turned on. A brand counts as named when its name or a common short form of it appears in the answer text, whether it is the top pick or one of several options. A link to the brand's website without its name does not count as a mention, and we track links separately. A small AI model also reads each answer for the companies it puts forward, which keeps a common word that is also a brand name from counting. Each ranking covers the last 30 days, which is about four answers to each question on each engine. AI answers change from one asking to the next, so every share comes with its likely range, a 95% interval for the number of answers behind it. In AI coding assistants, some engines are made by companies that also sell a coding tool, so every page shows each engine's share on its own beside the total. We publish the questions, the brand list, and the date of each run so anyone can check the work.
The questions
- cheapest car insurance for a new driver
- best car insurance for a family with a teen driver
- best car insurance company for claims service
- best car insurance for someone with a speeding ticket
- best car insurance for seniors
- best car insurance for a driver with a DUI on record
- best usage based car insurance that tracks driving to lower the price
- best car insurance for military families
- best car insurance for an electric car
- which car insurance company has the best app
- best car insurance for someone who rarely drives
- best car insurance to bundle with home insurance
- best car insurance for a gig driver doing rideshare or delivery
- best car insurance for a classic car
- best car insurance for good drivers with a clean record
- best car insurance for college students away from home
- cheapest full coverage car insurance
- best car insurance after an accident raised my rates
- best car insurance for a leased car with gap coverage
- best car insurance company in rural areas
The brands
- GEICO, geico.com
- Progressive, progressive.com
- State Farm, statefarm.com
- Allstate, allstate.com
- USAA, usaa.com
- Liberty Mutual, libertymutual.com
- Farmers Insurance, farmers.com
- Nationwide, nationwide.com
- Travelers, travelers.com
- American Family Insurance, amfam.com
- Erie Insurance, erieinsurance.com
- Root Insurance, joinroot.com
- Lemonade, lemonade.com
- Auto-Owners Insurance, auto-owners.com