Ask three AIs for the best plumber, get 18 names

We asked three AIs for the best plumber, dentist, lawyer, and more in three cities. They named 18 to 22 businesses per search and agreed on about one.

Mike Wilson · November 16, 2026 · 4 min read

Free, no card, first answers in under a minute.

Ask an AI who to call and it names a few businesses. So we asked three AI models the question a customer would ask, “Who is the best plumber in Denver?”, and the same for seven other services in three cities.

AI does not have one answer. It has a short list that changes with every model and every asking, and the businesses on it are the ones that show up on the sites AI reads.

What we asked

Eight services, four local and four professional. Plumber, HVAC company, dentist, and roofer. Personal injury lawyer, accountant for a small business, marketing agency for a small business, and financial advisor.

Three cities, Denver, Austin, and Columbus, Ohio.

Three AI models with web search on, Perplexity, OpenAI’s GPT, and Google’s Gemini. We asked each one every question three times, which makes nine answers per search and 216 answers in all. A second model read each answer for the businesses it named, and names written two ways for one business, like “Applewood” and “Applewood Plumbing Heating & Electric”, were merged into one.

How many businesses each search named

For a local service, the nine answers to one search named 18 different businesses on average. Only 1.3 of them, on average, were named by all three AIs.

Some searches did have a clear favorite. Applewood Plumbing Heating & Electric was named by all three for a plumber in Denver, and Kidd Roofing, Wilson Roofing, and LOA Construction & Roofing for a roofer in Austin.

Dentists had none. In Denver, Austin, and Columbus alike, not one dentist was named by all three AIs. Each AI had its own list, and the lists barely touched.

Professional services were wider still. A search for an injury lawyer, an accountant, a marketing agency, or a financial advisor named 22 different firms on average, and again only 1.3 were named by all three.

The full tables, search by search, are on local and home services and professional services.

The same AI changes its mind

We asked each AI every question three times. Of the businesses an AI named, it named only 64% again when asked the same local question again, and 53% for professional services.

A business that checks once and sees its name may not be named for the next customer who asks. Ask several times and count how often you are named.

How many businesses each AI names

The three AIs answer in different shapes. Nearly half of GPT’s local answers, 17 of 36, named just one business.

AIBusinesses named per answer, localFirms named per answer, professional
OpenAI’s GPT1.72.7
Perplexity5.45.9
Gemini7.26.9

So check each AI on its own. A business can be fifth on Gemini’s list and missing from GPT entirely.

Where AI reads before it answers

Perplexity and GPT show the pages they read. Gemini’s links are wrapped in Google redirects, so we left them out. These are the sites cited most in the 72 local answers with readable sources.

SiteShare of local answers citing it
bbb.org39%
forbes.com, its city best-of lists38%
5starhomeservicepros.com33%
expertise.com28%
consumeraffairs.com22%
yahoo.com22%
houzz.com21%
bestprosintown.com19%

For professional services the list was different. These are the sites cited most in the 72 professional answers with readable sources.

SiteShare of professional answers citing it
expertise.com35%
clutch.co, for accountants and agencies alike25%
themanifest.com, for accountants and agencies alike25%
bark.com21%
bestlawyers.com17%
quickbooks.intuit.com, its accountant directory14%
agencies.semrush.com14%
thumbtack.com13%
clearlyrated.com13%
money.usnews.com13%

Your own website matters too, but these are the pages AI read most before it named its list. Most of them are directories and best-of lists a business can get onto, with a complete profile, reviews, or a pitch to the editor.

What to do about it

  1. Ask more than once. Ask the AIs your customers use, each several times, in your city, in the words a customer would use. Count how often you are named, not whether you were named once.
  2. Get onto the sites AI reads. Start with the directories and best-of lists above for your service. A missing or thin profile on Expertise.com or BBB can leave you off the list.
  3. Make your own pages answer the question. Say plainly what you do, where, for whom, and why you are the right pick. AI quotes pages that answer the question it was asked.
  4. Check each AI on its own. Each reads a different mix of sources and names a different number of businesses.

Limits

This is one round, run on November 16, 2026, through each model’s API with web search on. The ChatGPT and Gemini apps a person uses can answer differently from the models behind them. Three cities and eight services are a sample, not the whole country, and nine answers per search show the spread, not a precise share. We will run it again and publish the change.

If you want to see where your own business stands, we run the same kind of check on your business across six AIs, free.

Check your AI visibility free.

See what Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, and one AI model tell your customers, and what to change. Free, no card, first answers in under a minute.